Mascara is a staple in many makeup routines, enhancing lashes and adding drama to the eyes. It’s a versatile product that can create various looks, from subtle definition to bold, voluminous lashes. As consumers become more conscious of their beauty choices, cruelty-free mascaras have gained popularity.
Cruelty-free mascaras are developed without animal testing, offering a compassionate alternative for those who want to look good while aligning with their ethical values. These products come in various formulas, including lengthening, volumizing, and waterproof options. They’re made by brands committed to creating cosmetics without harming animals.
When choosing a cruelty-free mascara, it’s essential to consider the brush shape, formula consistency, and ingredients. The brush design affects how the product is applied and the final look. Formula consistency can range from wet to dry, impacting application and wear time.
We carefully examined and tested numerous cruelty-free mascaras to find options that deliver excellent performance without compromising on ethics.
Best Cruelty-Free Mascaras
We’ve carefully selected the top cruelty-free mascaras that deliver stunning lashes without harming animals. Our list features kind-to-animals formulas that give you bold, beautiful lashes while aligning with your ethical values. Let’s explore these lash-enhancing wonders that prove beauty doesn’t have to come at a cost to our furry friends.
Lash Princess False Lash Mascara
We think this budget-friendly mascara delivers impressive results for those seeking dramatic, voluminous lashes without breaking the bank.
- Adds noticeable length and volume
- Cruelty-free and free from harmful ingredients
- Affordable price point
- Can clump if not applied carefully
- Brush may be too large for some
- May not suit those preferring a natural look
We were pleasantly surprised by the performance of this essence mascara. Upon first application, we noticed how it instantly transformed our lashes, giving them a fuller, more dramatic appearance.
The conic-shaped fiber brush did an excellent job of coating each lash from root to tip, creating a false lash effect without the need for actual falsies.
The formula felt lightweight on our lashes, and we appreciated that it’s free from gluten, silicones, parabens, and other potentially harmful ingredients. It’s always a bonus when we can find effective cosmetics that align with our clean beauty values. Plus, the fact that it’s cruelty-free makes us feel good about our purchase. Additionally, our overall makeup experience was enhanced by how well it blended with other products, ensuring a seamless and natural look. We also couldn’t help but draw parallels to our skincare routine, where we prioritize similar values—like choosing sulfatefree shampoo benefits that keep our hair healthy without harsh chemicals. It’s comforting to know that we can make choices for both our skin and hair that are kind to our bodies and the planet.
We found the mascara lasted well throughout the day, maintaining its volumizing effect without flaking or smudging. While it did take a bit of practice to avoid clumping, we discovered that wiping excess product off the brush before application helped achieve a smoother result.
For the price, we think this mascara offers incredible value, rivaling the performance of much pricier options we’ve tried in the past.
CoverGirl’s Clean Volume Lash Booster
We think this vegan mascara is a must-have for those seeking cruelty-free, voluminous lashes without compromising on quality or ethics. Not only does this mascara deliver stunning volume and length, but it is also made with sustainable ingredients that are gentle on sensitive eyes. Pair it with vegan eye shadows for bold looks that truly make a statement. You’ll feel confident and beautiful, knowing that your makeup choices align with your values.
- Impressive 10x volume boost
- Clean, vegan formula
- Smudge-proof and long-lasting
- May be tricky to remove
- Some users report a strong scent
- Not waterproof
We’ve been on the hunt for a mascara that ticks all the boxes, and CoverGirl’s Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara comes pretty close. The first thing we noticed was how easily it glided onto our lashes, separating and defining them without any clumps.
The brush is a game-changer. It’s designed to reach every lash, even those tiny ones in the corners. We found ourselves wiggling it from side to side, just as suggested, and were amazed at how it lifted and shaped our lashes.
What really sets this mascara apart is its clean, vegan formula. Infused with argan and marula oils, it left our lashes feeling nourished rather than brittle. We appreciated the absence of parabens, sulfates, talc, and mineral oil – it’s like a spa day for your lashes!
ILIA’s Lovely Lash Enhancer
We think this clean mascara is a must-try for those seeking natural-looking lashes with added length and definition.
- Fortifies and nourishes lashes
- Clump-free, flake-resistant formula
- Safe for sensitive eyes and contact wearers
- Pricey compared to some alternatives
- May smudge if eyes water
- Can be tricky to remove
We’ve been loving ILIA’s Limitless Lash Mascara lately. Its dual-sided wand is a game-changer, catching even the tiniest lashes for a full, eye-opening effect.
The formula glides on smoothly, resisting clumps and flakes throughout the day.
What really sets this mascara apart is its nourishing ingredients. Arginine strengthens lashes from within, while organic shea butter and beeswax add moisture. Our lashes felt soft and healthy, not brittle or dry like with some other mascaras we’ve tried.
One thing to note: while it holds up well in most conditions, it can smudge a bit if your eyes water. But for us, the beautiful, natural-looking results are worth it. Plus, we love that it’s vegan, cruelty-free, and safe for sensitive eyes. If you’re after lush lashes without harsh chemicals, give this one a go.
e.l.f. Lash ‘N Roll Mascara
We think this mascara is a game-changer for those seeking cruelty-free, lash-lifting magic at a wallet-friendly price.
- Impressive curl and lift
- Smudge-resistant formula
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- May clump with multiple coats
- Can be tricky to remove
- Brown shade availability limited
We’ve been on the hunt for the perfect mascara, and e.l.f.’s Lash ‘N Roll might just be it. The unique double-sided brush caught our eye, and boy, did it deliver!
One swipe, and our lashes were reaching for the stars. The curved silicone brush separated each lash beautifully, giving us that wide-eyed, “I woke up like this” look.
The formula is a dream to work with. It’s not too wet, not too dry – just right for building volume without turning our lashes into spidery messes. We loved how it stayed put throughout the day, resisting smudges and flakes like a champ.
And the best part? No need for a lash curler! This little wonder tube did all the heavy lifting for us.
As clean beauty enthusiasts, we’re thrilled that e.l.f. keeps it kind with 100% vegan and cruelty-free ingredients. The Lash ‘N Roll feels like a high-end product without the hefty price tag. While it may take a bit of practice to master (and a good makeup remover at night), we think it’s worth every penny for those seeking va-va-voom lashes without compromising their values.
Honest Beauty 2-in-1 Extreme Length Mascara
We believe this dual-ended mascara and primer combo is a must-have for those seeking luscious, cruelty-free lashes with clean ingredients.
- Dual-ended design for convenience
- Lengthening and volumizing effects
- Clean, cruelty-free formula
- Primer may take getting used to
- Slightly crumbly texture
- Smaller tube size
We’ve been using this Honest Beauty mascara for a while now, and we’re impressed with its performance. The dual-ended design is genius – one side for the primer and the other for the mascara. It’s a breeze to apply, even for makeup newbies like us.
The primer creates a great base, helping the mascara adhere better and last longer. We noticed a significant boost in length and volume after application. Our lashes looked fuller and more defined without feeling heavy or clumpy.
We love that it’s made with clean ingredients and is cruelty-free. No need to worry about harmful chemicals near our eyes. The formula feels lightweight, and we found it easy to remove at the end of the day. While it may not be completely smudge-proof, it holds up well for everyday wear.
Buying Guide
Choosing the perfect cruelty-free mascara can be tricky. We’ve put together some tips to help you find your ideal lash enhancer.
Formula
Look for mascaras with natural, plant-based ingredients. Organic options are great for sensitive eyes. Avoid formulas with harsh chemicals or synthetic dyes.
Brush Type
The brush shape affects how the mascara applies:
- Curved: Lifts and curls lashes
- Straight: Lengthens and separates
- Tapered: Reaches corner lashes easily
Performance
Consider what you want your mascara to do:
- Volumizing
- Lengthening
- Curling
- Defining
Wear Time
Think about how long you need your mascara to last. Some formulas are designed for all-day wear, while others are better for shorter periods.
Removal
Opt for easily removable mascaras if you have sensitive skin. Water-resistant formulas may require special makeup removers.
Packaging
We love brands that use eco-friendly packaging. Look for recyclable tubes or containers made from sustainable materials.
Certifications
Check for trusted cruelty-free certifications like Leaping Bunny or PETA. These ensure the product wasn’t tested on animals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Navigating the world of cruelty-free mascaras can be tricky. We’ve compiled answers to some common questions to help you find the perfect lash-enhancing product that aligns with your values.
What’s the top rated cruelty-free mascara right now?
Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara is currently making waves. It’s vegan, affordable, and gives lashes incredible volume and length. We love how it doesn’t clump or flake, even after hours of wear.
Can I find quality cruelty-free mascaras at drugstores?
Absolutely! Many drugstores now stock excellent cruelty-free options. NYX Professional Makeup and e.l.f. Cosmetics offer great mascaras that are kind to animals and your wallet. We’ve found their formulas rival high-end brands in terms of performance.
Are there cruelty-free mascaras good for sensitive eyes?
Yes! Brands like Tarte and Pacifica create gentle formulas perfect for sensitive peepers. We recommend looking for mascaras labeled hypoallergenic or ophthalmologist-tested. These tend to be less irritating and great for contact lens wearers too.
Which brands have the best waterproof mascaras that don’t test on animals?
Urban Decay and Too Faced offer fantastic waterproof mascaras that stay put through tears, sweat, and even a dip in the pool. We’re impressed by their long-lasting formulas that don’t compromise on ethics or performance.
How do you know if a mascara is truly cruelty-free?
Look for certifications from organizations like PETA or Leaping Bunny. Check the brand’s website for their animal testing policy. We also suggest researching if the company sells in China, where animal testing is often required by law.
Are there any Leaping Bunny certified mascaras that pros swear by?
Hourglass Cosmetics and Milk Makeup both carry Leaping Bunny certified mascaras that makeup artists love. These brands are used backstage at fashion shows and on red carpets. Their mascaras deliver professional-level results without compromising on ethics.